What was the best ever PGA Championship Playoff?

The PGA Championship is one of golf’s great tournaments that hasn’t stopped producing incredible playoffs throughout the years.

The Wanamaker Trophy is one of the most sought-after pieces of silverware in the game and it has been won by the best players to have ever picked up a club.

Recent winners of the trophy include Brooks Koepka, Justin Thomas, Phil Mickelson and Collin Morikawa – the PGA Championship never disappoints.

And sometimes, this event has been decided by a playoff – most recently in 2022 when Thomas beat Will Zalatoris at Southern Hills in Tulsa.

Let’s take a look below at the PGA Championship playoffs that stick in the mind for us the most:

What is the format for the playoff?

The PGA Championship playoff format uses a three-hole aggregate score system to determine a winner from the playoff. If the scores are still tied after the three holes then sudden-death holes would follow until a winner was determined.

However, this hasn’t always been the case. Up until the 2000 PGA Championship, where if the scores were still tied after the 72-hole tournament, then the play-off would go straight to sudden-death.

Before sudden death was introduced in 1968, it was an 18-hole play-off that was used to determine a winner.

ALSO: Unforgettable PGA Championships

2011 Keegan Bradley vs Jason Dufner

Keegan Bradley won the 2011 PGA Championship at Atlantic Athletic Club to defeat fellow American Jason Dufner to win his first major title. At one point on the Sunday afternoon, Bradley was five shots behind Dufner with just three holes to play.

However, three consecutive bogeys by Dufner and back-to-back birdies by Bradley saw them tied after 72 holes and needing a three-hole play-off to determine a winner.

The playoff started on the par-4 16th, which Bradley birdied thanks to an approach to four feet. Dufner parred the hole. A bogey at the par-3 17th by Dufner gave Bradley a two-shot lead with one to play after he parred the hole.

On the 18th, both players hit the green in regulation, and Dufner had to make his 20-footer to have any chance of keeping the playoff alive. He duly did, and Bradley needed to two-putt to win his first major title, and he did so.

Keegan Bradley became the first player since Ben Curtis at the 2003 Open Championship to win on their major debut, and also became the first player to win with the now-banned belly (long) putter.

“I can’t believe it, I feel so proud,” said Bradley, who is also the nephew of LPGA Tour legend Pat Bradley.

“It seems like a dream, and I’m afraid I’m going to wake up here in the next five minutes and it’s not going to be real. It’s an honour to be champion of the PGA. My father is a PGA member and it’s just great.”

2010 Martin Kaymer vs Bubba Watson

The 2010 PGA Championship at Whistling Straits was won in a playoff by Germany’s Martin Kaymer, who defeated the American Bubba Watson.

The tournament is most remembered for the controversy on the 72nd hole with another American, Dustin Johnson, who bogeyed the hole to get into the playoff but afterwards in the scorers hut was assessed a two-stroke penalty for grounding his club in a bunker, meaning he made a triple-bogey seven and missed the playoff by two shots.

That left Kaymer and Watson to battle it out over three holes. Both players were one-under-par after two holes, but a double-bogey 6 at the 18th in the third play-off hole allowed Kaymer to win his first major.

“I don’t really realise what was just happening today. Obviously it was a very exciting week, and to win – I hope it’s one of many majors that I will win in my career, it’s spectacular.”

ALSO: What are the perks of winning the PGA Championship?

2000 Tiger Woods vs Bob May

Tiger Woods had a titanic battle with Bob May in the 2000 PGA Championship at Valhalla.

Both players shot 18-under par for the tournament and 31 (-5) for the back nine on Sunday. They both birdied the 72nd hole in regulation play to go into the first-ever three-hole aggregate play-off in the tournament’s history.

Woods birdied the first play-off hole whilst May parred the first. Both players parred the next two, and Woods won his fifth major title and his second PGA Championship, the first in 1999.

NOW READ: Where will the PGA Championship be held in 2026, 2027 and 2028?

NOW READ: PGA Championship field 2025: Who is playing at Quail Hollow?

NOW READ: A look into the history of the PGA Championship

Tell us your favourite PGA Championship Playoff memory on X!