fbpx
Bernhard Langer WITB 2020

Masters champions debate: Should they get lifetime exemption?

Augusta National offers lifetime exemption to past champions, but is it time for that to change? Dan Murphy and Alex Perry discuss

 

Masters champions, if you didn’t know, are allowed to continue playing in the Augusta showpiece for as long as they so wish.

It’s the same motley crew every year – Fred Couples, Bernhard Langer, Vijay Singh, Mike Weir, Sandy Lyle and so on. If social media is anything to go by, golf fans are split down the middle on this one. And, it seems, so are we…

‘Is there a moment when it just becomes demeaning for past champions of the Masters?’

I write as someone who would rather stumble across a champion of vintage like Sandy Lyle or Mark Calcavecchia around the turn on the first day of The Open than a tour stalwart who has got in through qualifying, writes Dan Murphy.

But watching Mike Weir, the 2003 Masters Tournament champion, open up with a double bogey at Augusta made me wonder why he would want to bother.

Especially these days when all the gory details are available on the Masters website within moments. The drive went 220 yards, and not in a straight line. The second was low and out of the heel and, I suspect, not entirely unrelated to a top. The pitch was, shall we say, conservative.

The first putt was quite good. The second might have grazed the hole, at best, from two feet.

I am (easily) old enough to remember watching Weir win his Green Jacket. Who am I to scoff at his major-winning golf game, now or ever?

I just wonder if there is a moment when it becomes demeaning or even embarrassing to these champions. When basking in the glory of their career highlights turns into something rather less enjoyable. When the reality bites that this is a 7,600-yard golf course set up to test the very best on a cold and damp Georgia morning.

Maybe Nick Faldo, ever the pragmatist, had the right idea when he hung up his spikes once it was clear that he was no longer a competitor.

Masters champions

ALSO: A peek into the history of the Masters

‘It’s their greatest achievement and they should be allowed to relive it’

This may surprise regular readers of my Slam column, writes Alex Perry, but this is one area of golf in which I am absolutely on the side of tradition.

Yes, there may be times when you’re watching past Masters champions through your fingers as they struggle to break 80, but for every Mike Weir there’s a Fred Couples or a Bernhard Langer notching a top-20 to keep that nostalgia fire burning.

But even for those who struggle, who cares? What a genuine honour it must be to go back to the scene of your greatest triumph. They take their family, they take their grandchildren. For at least two days a year, they will feel a foot taller.

As for the fans, it will be the last chance to get to see some of their favourites from yesteryear, whether it be an Arnold Palmer or a Jack Nicklaus or a Tiger Woods. I mean, they’re there for the Masters Champions dinner anyway, so why not?

Do I care that everyone’s favourite Canadian left-hander is only popping it 220 off the tee? Of course not. I’m not judging them on that, in any way. I’m happy for them that they’re here and enjoying their moment.

I would do the same. So would Dan. And so, dear reader, would you.

NOW READ: Why do caddies wear large, white suits at the Masters?

NOW READ: What is the Butler Cabin at Augusta?

Follow NCG on X/Twitter!

NCG

Latest Posts

scottie scheffler masters

The Masters

The dominant force: Who can stop Scottie Scheffler now?

By

Read full article about The dominant force: Who can stop Scottie Scheffler now?
masters final round

The Masters

Scottie Scheffler strolls to second Masters victory at Augusta National

By

Read full article about Scottie Scheffler strolls to second Masters victory at Augusta National
Tiger Woods major

The Masters

There is still nothing like watching Tiger Woods at a major

By

Read full article about There is still nothing like watching Tiger Woods at a major

The Masters

Gnome sweet gnome: Hunting for the Masters must-buy souvenir

By

Read full article about Gnome sweet gnome: Hunting for the Masters must-buy souvenir
masters round three tee times

The Masters

2024 Masters Sunday tee times: Round 4 groupings

By

Read full article about 2024 Masters Sunday tee times: Round 4 groupings
masters day two

The Masters

Scheffler shines while Morikawa charges on day three at the Masters

By

Read full article about Scheffler shines while Morikawa charges on day three at the Masters
jason day malbon

The Masters

Take it off! Augusta National asked Jason Day to remove Malbon vest

By

Read full article about Take it off! Augusta National asked Jason Day to remove Malbon vest
masters moving day

The Masters

Masters moving day is gloriously old school

By

Read full article about Masters moving day is gloriously old school
collin morikawa witb

The Masters

What’s in Collin Morikawa’s bag?

By

Read full article about What’s in Collin Morikawa’s bag?