NCG Top 100s: Scotland - 'My top three' - National Club Golfer

Our team have played copious Scottish courses ahead of compiling the NCG Top 100s: Scotland list – but which courses make the top three for our panellists?

Scotland is home to some incredible golf courses, the birthplace of links golf and history around every corner from the early days of the sport.

To pick just three courses across the nation requires clear criteria. Is it playability, is it cost, is it the views? Rankings are subjective, but a few notable places reign supreme over the rest.

Everyone knows the Open Championship rota courses, but there are so many more to discover.

But what did our panellists think? They all will have played different courses, so their top threes will be different, or will they…?

Which NCG Top 100s: Scotland courses make our panellists’ top three?

Phil Bedford

1 – The Old Course: the history
2 – Carnoustie: the challenge and condition
3 – Machrihanish: the journey, the scenery, the first sixteen holes are fabulous

David Fox

1 – Western Gailes: perfect condition, stunning views, epic dunes, and the greens were exceptional
2 – Dunbar: Stunning setting, quirky shaping, a true links
3 – Castle Stuart: Impeccable throughout

Jim Marshall
1 – Muirfield for its tradition and world-class golf course
2 – Loch Lomond for luxury, class and scenery
3 – Western Gailes for pure links magic.

Jim Banting
1 – Turnberry Ailsa: great layout and use of extraordinary links landscape
2 – Royal Dornoch: great condition and presentation with bags of charm
3 – Carnoustie: challenging, playable and great flow to holes

Craig Medston

1: Cruden Bay
2: Western Gailes
3: Machrihanish

RELATED: What is the best opening hole in Scotland? – COMING SOON
RELATED: What is the best closing hole in Scotland? – COMING SOON
RELATED: What is the best hole in Scotland? – COMING SOON

Muirfield golf course review — *Muirfield – one of several Open venues in Scotland – appears on many a top three of our panel*

Chris Myatt
Royal Dornoch and Machrihanish for their pure links nature and views, and Muirfield for its strategy and atmosphere.

Oliver Baker
Royal Dornoch, Muirfield, The Old Course. All have great routings, a fantastic set of greens that take plenty of learning, numerous strategic options, wonderful views and setting.

Peter Rudd
1: St Andrews Old Course – unrivalled tradition
2: Kingsbarns – simply the best modern links with a great location
3: Carnoustie – great test and always in superb condition

Craig Morrison
Royal Dornoch, Machrihanish and Machrihanish Dunes. For me, they’re freedom, happiness and excellence.

Dove Jones
1 – Alisa: not a bad hole or approach shot
2 – Castle St Andrews: Always loved it – love the green complexes, quirky fun with great views (despite the haters)
3 – Queens: heathland classic, scoreable

Michael Verity
1: The Old Course – Tough to say something original about TOC. It just connects with me in a way nowhere else does.
2: Muirfield – High level just never drops throughout the round. Outstanding
3: Royal Dornoch

RELATED: Our panellists highlight of playing golf in Scotland in 2025 – COMING SOON
RELATED: Which Scottish courses are underrated? – COMING SOON
RELATED: Which part of Scotland is the best when it comes to golf? – COMING SOON

best Scottish links holes — *Machrihanish is just one of several stunning courses on the Mull of Kintyre…*

Hugh Masson
1: Royal Dornoch – Exceeded my lofty expectations.
2: Elie – An invigorating experience. It transcends golf.
3: Castle Stuart – An expertly crafted course that pleases the eye at every turn.

Charles Abraham
The Old Course, Trump Turnberry and Muirfield. The Old Course operates on a different level to anything else on this list.

Ed Battye
1: St Andrews Old – The Holy Grail
2: Askernish – Beautifully raw golf distilled to its origins; a mix of simplistic brilliance & crazy genius
3: North Berwick – An eccentrically brilliant links, beyond quirky.

Steve Watton
1: Trump Turnberry
2: Royal Dornoch
3: Muirfield

David Elliott
1: Elie – because of its charm and stunning views.
2: Loch Lomond – because of its grandeur and stunning views.
3: Royal Dornoch – because of its playability and stunning views.

RELATED: What is the best par 3 in Scotland? – COMING SOON
RELATED: What is the best par 4 in Scotland? – COMING SOON
RELATED: What is the best par 5 in Scotland? – COMING SOON

Castle Stuart golf course review — *Castle Stuart, now one of two layouts at Cabot Highlands, features several times among our panel’s favourites*

Chris Griffiths
1: North Berwick – Incredible
2: Dunbar – Close 2nd, and I would love to be a member here.
3: Mortonhall – Nice parkland course and very nice to play a different type of course than the others.

David Walker
1 – Muirfield
2 – Ailsa
3 – Royal Dornoch
Historic courses where strategy is critical

Paul Watson
1 – The Old Course: It has a huge history and a unique atmosphere.
2 – Muirfield: Its history and layout tests all golfers
3 – Gleneagles King’s: Its beautiful location and challenge

Ian Woods
1 – Cruden Bay. Abundance of drama.
2 – North Berwick. Quirkiness and views.
3 – St Andrews Old Course. History and atmosphere.

Neil White
1: Turnberry Ailsa – just magnificent in every possible way
2: St Andrews Old Course – famous holes, brilliant design, a lifetime memory
3: Cruden Bay – maybe the quirkiest and most fun course I’ve played

RELATED: What is the best view in Scottish golf? – COMING SOON
RELATED: Where do our panellists want to visit next? – COMING SOON
RELATED: Which Scottish venues has the best putting surfaces? – COMING SOON

*One of the most iconic halfway houses in golf, situated on one of the most iconic golf courses – Turnberry’s Ailsa*

Andi White
1: St Andrews Old Course – variety of holes, undulations, and shared greens.
2: Nairn – fabulous green complexes, with great bunkers, drop-offs and undulations
3: Royal Troon – amazing condition and so tough

Stu Bennett
Royal Dornoch, Kingsbarns, Muirfield – all challenging with great green complexes and par 3s that are difficult to match

Michael Atkinson
Royal Dornoch, Gullane No 1 and Turnberry’s Ailsa course. Three historic links courses, all in very different parts of Scotland, but each filled with great character and personality.

Lewis Marr
1: The Old Course – an unrivalled sense of history.
2: Cruden Bay – wild and fun.
3: Trump Aberdeen – visually impressive.

Trump International 3rd hole — *Trump International’s Old Course – one of Scotland’s great new layout*s

NOW READ: What is the hardest hole in Scotland?
NOW READ: Which courses surprised our panellists the most? – COMING SOON

Now have your say

Visit the NCG Top 100s: Scotland page, click on a course you have played and leave a review on our website!

What are your memories of playing golf in Scotland? What would you put in your own top three? Let us know your thoughts with a post on X, formerly Twitter!