Skip to content
    • Tour Homepage
    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
    • Equipment Homepage
    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
    • Instruction Homepage
    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Magazine
    • Why walking is how golf is meant to be played
    • Why walking is the only way to truly appreciate a golf course
National Club GolferNational Club Golfer Logo
  • TourHas submenu items

    Tour Homepage

    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
  • EquipmentHas submenu items

    Equipment Homepage

    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
  • ClubHas submenu items
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
  • InstructionHas submenu items

    Instruction Homepage

    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
  • CoursesHas submenu items
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
  • PodcastsHas submenu items
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Magazine
  • The Joy of WalkingHas submenu items
    • Why walking is how golf is meant to be played
    • Why walking is the only way to truly appreciate a golf course

Sign up here for our newsletter and you'll never slice a drive again. Promise.

Newsletter sign up

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
National Club Golfer Logo

© 2026 National Club Golfer | 2 Arena Park, Tam Lane, LS17 9BF

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Policy
  • Meet the NCG Team
  • Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions
Country: gb Page generated at: Sunday, 7 June 2026 at 15:03:43 British Summer Time
tour
Tour
US Girls match semi-final ends in gimme controversy

published: Jul 30, 2017

|

updated: Jul 11, 2023

US Girls match semi-final ends in gimme controversy

Matthew BeedleLink

FacebookXInstagramYouTubePodcast0 comments

When is a gimme not a gimme? When it’s not given, of course. See the video below…

US Girls match semi-final ends in gimme controversy

Table of Contents

Jump to:

  • amazing golf recovery shots
  • who will be mcilroy’s next caddie?
  • golfing world divided by news of mcilroy firing his caddie

Cast your minds back to the gimme controversy in the 2015 Solheim Cup involving Suzann Petterson and Allison Lee. The Norwegian claimed that she hadn’t given the American’s their two foot putt and therefore Europe won the hole.

Well, the exact situation happened during the semi-final of the US Girls Junior match play. Erica Shepherd had completed the first extra hole – the par-5 14th – with a par so Elizabeth Moon stood over a birdie putt to win the match and had a chance to move into the final.

Moon’s putt missed on the underside of the hole before immediately raking the ball back and practised the same putt, knocking the ball into the hole.

Unfortunately for Moon controversy would follow. Shepherd straight away turned to her coach and said: “I never said that was good.”

After a conversation with the rules official Moon was given a one shot penalty for moving her ball.

If you didn’t see it, here is the incident…

This is an absolute disgrace. pic.twitter.com/wpef50qZPn

— Mark Harris (@TweetsByHarris) July 29, 2017

The ruling has divided opinion amongst the golfing world. Moon shouldn’t have presumed the putt had been given but on the other hand should common sense come into play? She wouldn’t have missed.

Shepherd went on to win the competition by defeating Jennifer Chang in the final 3&2.

Amazing golf recovery shots

Amazing golf recovery shots

Read full article - Amazing golf recovery shots
McIlroy caddie latest odds

Who will be McIlroy’s next caddie?

Read full article - Who will be McIlroy’s next caddie?
Golfing world divided by news of McIlroy firing his caddie

Golfing world divided by news of McIlroy firing his caddie

Read full article - Golfing world divided by news of McIlroy firing his caddie

Advertisement

About the author

Matthew Beedle

Matthew has been playing golf since he was around 13 and took up the game at a local nine-hole municipal course with his friends before joining Pontefract & District Golf Club just over the hedge.

Still a member of Pontefract with a handicap of 3, he currently sits on the board of directors to help with digital and marketing initiatives in order to improve membership and visitor income.

Matthew graduated university with a First Class in Sports Journalism from Leeds Trinity University and has been working in the golf industry since graduating.

NCG’s social media & marketing manager, Matthew’s main job role is to increase website traffic to the National Club Golfer website via our email and social media channels as well as driving entries to grow our NCG Top 100s Tour events amongst other tasks.

Not one to change his equipment too often, Matthew currently plays the TaylorMade M2 driver which has lasted the test of time in his bag. Elsewhere, you’ll find him using the TaylorMade Stealth 2 three-wood with a Ping G425 Crossover 2-iron to aid his long game.

Through his 4-iron to Gap Wedge, Matthew uses the Ping i500 irons accompanied by Ping’s Glide 3.0 56-degree and 60-degree wedges.

Another club that has stood the test of time in his bag is a Nike Method Core MC-3i putter which has had to have the SuperStroke grip changed at least three times. Ball of choice is the Titleist ProV1.

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

What's Popular

Discover the Best Golf Gloves 2026 for Maximum Grip and Comfort

By Max Mcvittie | May 24, 2026

Read full article Discover the Best Golf Gloves 2026 for Maximum Grip and Comfort
Garrick Higgo looks over a putt at the PGA Championship | Source: Getty Images

Garrick Higgo’s PGA Championship penalty is a warning for every club golfer

By Steve Carroll | May 14, 2026

Read full article Garrick Higgo’s PGA Championship penalty is a warning for every club golfer
foursomes Golfers at a green | Source: Adobe Stock

What does ‘equity’ mean in the World Handicap System?

By Steve Carroll | May 21, 2026

Read full article What does ‘equity’ mean in the World Handicap System?

Best Budget Irons 2026

By | Mar 5, 2026

Read full article Best Budget Irons 2026
richest golfers of all time

Who are the richest golfers of all time?

By Matt Chivers | Oct 1, 2025

Read full article Who are the richest golfers of all time?
Three golfers on the tee | Source: Adobe Stock

WHS allows you to play from different tees in competitions – so why do some golf clubs still ignore this?

By Max Mcvittie | May 28, 2026

Read full article WHS allows you to play from different tees in competitions – so why do some golf clubs still ignore this?
Major champion Aaron Rai | Source: Getty Images

Who is PGA Champion Aaron Rai?

By Matt Coles | Jul 1, 2024

Read full article Who is PGA Champion Aaron Rai?
ST ANDREWS, SCOTLAND - JULY 17: Cameron Smith of Australia celebrates after putting on the 18th green during Day Four of The 150th Open at St Andrews Old Course on July 17, 2022 in St Andrews, Scotland. (Photo by Charlie Crowhurst/R&A/R&A via Getty Images)

At £190, has The Open Championship crossed the line and become too expensive?

By Matt Chivers | Jun 4, 2026

Read full article At £190, has The Open Championship crossed the line and become too expensive?
Bryson DeChambeau at LIV Golf Korea | Source: LIV Golf

Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?

By Matt Chivers | Jun 3, 2026

Read full article Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?
Dustin Johnson. Peter Uihlein and Branden Grace | Source: LIV Golf

How much has each LIV golfer made compared to their PGA Tour earnings?

By Matt Chivers | Jun 3, 2026

Read full article How much has each LIV golfer made compared to their PGA Tour earnings?
golfers private jets

Which golfers own private jets and how much do they cost?

By Matt Coles | Oct 16, 2025

Read full article Which golfers own private jets and how much do they cost?

Best Golf Balls for Seniors 2026: Distance and feel for those with slower swing speeds

By Max Mcvittie | May 22, 2026

Read full article Best Golf Balls for Seniors 2026: Distance and feel for those with slower swing speeds