An unexpected story about a great comeback emerged at the 2025 US Open.
About a former World No. 1 recapturing old glories to once again stand near the summit at a major championship.
That should’ve been the focus of Adam Scott’s revival at Oakmont. The man with the smoothest swing in golf spent much of the last few years away from the major scene, despite not missing one of the big four events since 2001, and of course, with the memory of winning at Augusta National in 2013.
Sure, the anticipation around the former Masters champion looking to win that long-awaited second major was the main focus. But gripes about his putter always linger.
Whether or not Scott is anchoring his long putter against his chest – and I don’t for a moment think he is – is almost immaterial.
It’s the mere perception that he COULD be, and that there’s nothing that can be done about it, that is seriously damaging the game.
What is anchoring in golf?
I once sat in an England Golf rules meeting as the new anchoring laws were spelt out to championship referees in 2016.
Rule 14-1b (as it was back then) banned the anchoring of the club – either directly, when a player “intentionally holds the club or a gripping hand in contact with any part of his body”, or by the use of an anchor point.
That is deemed to be “when the player intentionally holds a forearm in contact with any part of his body to establish a gripping hand as a stable point around which the other hand may swing the club”.
Bizarrely, though, given the years of R&A and USGA hand-wringing and the controversies that got them to that point, the new rule didn’t ban either the long or the belly putter.
So the implements that had actually been the cause of much of the outcry were still permitted.
Advertisement
There were lots of infographics showing what was and wasn’t allowed – pictures of putters held away from the chest and various other parts of the body.
But it only took one raised hand for the illusion to come crashing down.
ALSO: Should long putters be banned from golf?
ALSO: Best Putters 2025
How can anchoring be policed?
What, mused one experienced official, could be done if there was a suspicion of anchoring but it wasn’t clear-cut?
Say a player was using a long putter in rainy conditions. They were wearing waterproofs, and it appeared they were anchoring the putter to their chest – perhaps imagine Scott in the rain at Oakmont in Pennsylvania.
How could that be proved? Was the putter simply touching the clothing, which isn’t a breach of the rules?
How could you actually tell if it was anchoring? How could you accurately assess whether a penalty was required?
The answer, as we understood it, was to rely on player integrity. Basically, if you said you weren’t anchoring, that was good enough for everyone unless there was concrete evidence to the contrary.
That’s because the act of anchoring, as defined in the rules, has to be intentional.
But like the silly form you fill in when you are going to a foreign country that asks you whether you are a terrorist, who is going to admit to anchoring?
And so we have this atmosphere of rancour each time a player who uses a long putter gets into contention – or employs a technique that bears the slightest suggestion that their stroke could be anchored.
Bernhard Langer, a player whose middle name could be ‘honesty’, has been fending off criticisms and accusations ever since the new rules came into effect because he uses a broom-handle.
What is the solution to end the debate around perceived anchoring?
Scott isn’t doing anything that is against the rules. He is following them to the letter.
But those rules are wrong. All they have done is promote suspicion among both players and spectators alike.
Perceptions are hugely important, and any suggestion of wrongdoing, whether valid or otherwise, is hurting the sport.
So it’s time for rulemakers to act, do what they should have in the first place and set concrete guidelines on putter lengths.
Sorry Adam, but the long putter has got to go.
NOW READ: Best Blade Putters 2025
NOW READ: Best Mallet Putters 2025
Would you ban anchoring in golf? Tell us on X!
Advertisement
