It was a row that threatened to drown the new Rules of Golf before they ever really got established. Haotong Li’s caddie got caught in the wrong place at the wrong time and both pros and amateurs on social media went mad.
Let’s briefly hark back to the 2019 Dubai Desert Classic. Defending champion Li was on the 18th green and it was decided his caddie was directly behind him when he took his stance. It was a breach of a new rule that restricted when a caddie could ‘deliberately’ stand when a player began to take a shot and it cost Li about $100,000.
There was a lot of noise about that decision afterwards, whether it was a marginal call or not, and the R&A and USGA responded quickly by issuing a clarification that spelled out when a player began taking a stance for a stroke and some examples of when that was not deliberate.
Rule 10.2b (4), though, was now getting so large it was starting to need a rule book of its own and so, for the 2023 Rules of Golf, the governing bodies have put together a re-write to clear it up once and for all. Let’s enter the restricted area…
Caddie standing behind player: What is the restricted area?
This comes into effect when a player begins to take a stance for the stroke. Rule 10.2b (4) defines that as having at least one foot in position for that stance.
Until the stroke is made there are limitations relating to when and why a “player’s caddie may deliberately stand on or close to an extension of the line of the play behind that ball”. That’s known as the restricted area and it covers two points: aiming and help other than aiming.
What’s the deal with aiming?
“The caddie must not stand in the restricted area to help the player with aiming”. All very straightforward. But there is more.
Advertisement
‘Help’ also includes when a caddie moves away – even without saying anything – but “by doing so, is giving a signal to the player that they are correctly aimed at the intended target”.
There is an escape clause. If the player backs away before making the stroke and the caddie moves away from the restricted area “before the player again begins to take a stance for the stroke” then there will be no penalty.
What about providing other help?
Rule 10.2b (4) says this is things like checking to see if a player’s club would hit a nearby tree during a backswing. Caddies can stand in the restricted area in such circumstances but only if they move away before the stroke is made and “provided this positioning is not part of a regular routine”.
There is no penalty for a caddie that’s inadvertently in the restricted area – the move must be deliberate.
What about if they’re helping to see where the ball went?
Ever tried to hit a ball in the low sun? You’ll often see someone lined up behind a player to get an idea of where the ball is flying when the shot is hit. Is this a breach of Rule 10.2b (4)?
The rule does not stop a player from getting help by having someone “other than the player’s caddie stand in the restricted area to help track the flight of a ball”.
Does this Rule only apply to caddies?
No. In forms of play that involve partners or advice givers the same restrictions apply, although there are modifications in place for players who are blind. There is also a further rule on when a player can stand behind their partner.
Caddie standing behind player: What if the rule is breached?
You’ll get the general penalty, which is two shots or loss or hole in match play.
Got a question for our expert?
Despite the changes to the Rules of Golf in 2019 and 2023, there are still some that leave us scratching our heads. I’ll try to help by featuring the best of your queries in this column.
What do you think about these caddie standing behind player rules? Let me know on X.
- NOW READ: My ball hit a marker on the green and went in – does it count?
- NOW READ: Five things you missed in the 2023 Rules of Golf update
Advertisement
