The armchair referees are out in force again – but what do the rules say about Harman’s antics?
Brian Harman’s troubles at the US Open set social media alight, but did the American go too far? Our Rules of Golf expert gives his verdict
Turning on social media during a major championship should come with a health warning. Particularly when it comes to the Rules of Golf.
When Brian Harman laid down his wedge as he was preparing to hit his fourth shot, from a collar of greenside rough on the 13th during the second round of the US Open in Brookline, it was soon at work.
He moved his ball, they said. He improved his lie, they exclaimed. It was against the rules, they insisted.
I aim to steer clear of emotion when it comes to assessing whether there is a breach. So let’s take a look at what happened to Harman at The Country Club and I’ll tell you how I’d apply the Rules of Golf if I was an official on site.
US Open rules: Did Brian Harman cause his ball to move?
Did the ball move?
People tend to get ahead of themselves when it comes to the rules. They click on google, slap in a term, and when the search engine spits something out they think they’ve got the answer.
But when I’m looking at a situation for the first time, I tend to ignore the numbers and subsections. For me, the rules start in the definitions.
If you crank through that alphabetical index, you’ll find there is a definition for ‘moved’. It goes like this: “When a ball at rest has left its original spot and come to rest on any other spot, and this can be seen by the naked eye.”
It also adds: “If the ball only wobbles (sometimes referred to as oscillating) and stays on or returns to its original spot, the ball has not moved.”
I’ve re-run the incident now a dozen times. The ball wobbles but I am happy it oscillates back in place, as the USGA, who reportedly looked at the incident, must have been as well.
Didn’t the club touch the ball?
If Harman had caused his ball to move, he’d have received a penalty stroke for doing so under Rule 9.4b.
It’s here where we also need to go to settle another of social media’s complaints – namely that he touched the ball.
Watching the replay, it’s not clear to me whether he touches the ball with his club or whether laying it in the grass is what causes the ball to oscillate.
Regardless of that, though, Rule 9.4b would only hand out a penalty here if a player lifted or deliberately touched his or her ball at rest.
There is a clarification to this rule that outlines where a one stroke sanction could be handed out if a ball is deliberately touched but not moved.
One of these is when a player “deliberately touches the ball with a club in preparing to make a stroke”.
But looking at the incident, can you be sure that’s what happened? Given that, as I said, it’s not clear whether the club was even touching the grass or the ball when it oscillated, there is no way I could say there was intent to touch it.
So, again, no penalty.
Were the conditions affecting the stroke improved?
Some commentators focused on this, arguing Harman was pushing down on his club, or applying pressure on it, when he laid it behind the ball when preparing to take the shot.
Rule 8.1b (4) allows a player to ground their club “lightly right in front of or right behind the ball” and not pick up a penalty – “even if doing so improves the conditions affecting the stroke”.
But a player is not allowed to press the club on the ground. The sanction for a breach of this rule is the general penalty (two strokes or loss of hole in match play).
Can we say this happens here?
In the first few seconds of the clip, when the footage is at its clearest, the rough looks like it springs back into place.
And if I scroll it through frame by frame, I can also see he hasn’t fully gripped the club in either instance and that the grass appears to be supporting the club. I can’t see how I could possibly call a penalty.
Got a question for our expert?
Despite the changes to the Rules of Golf in 2019 and 2023, there are still some that leave us scratching our heads. I’ll try to help by featuring the best of your queries in this column.
What do you think about this US Open rules drama with Brian Harman? Let me know by leaving a comment on X.
Steve Carroll
A journalist for 25 years, Steve has been immersed in club golf for almost as long. A former club captain, he has passed the Level 3 Rules of Golf exam with distinction having attended the R&A's prestigious Tournament Administrators and Referees Seminar.
Steve has officiated at a host of high-profile tournaments, including Open Regional Qualifying, PGA Fourball Championship, English Men's Senior Amateur, and the North of England Amateur Championship. In 2023, he made his international debut as part of the team that refereed England vs Switzerland U16 girls.
A part of NCG's Top 100s panel, Steve has a particular love of links golf and is frantically trying to restore his single-figure handicap. He currently floats at around 11.
Steve plays at Close House, in Newcastle, and York GC, where he is a member of the club's matches and competitions committee and referees the annual 36-hole scratch York Rose Bowl.
Having studied history at Newcastle University, he became a journalist having passed his NTCJ exams at Darlington College of Technology.
What's in Steve's bag: TaylorMade Stealth 2 driver, 3-wood, and hybrids; Caley 01T irons 4-PW; TaylorMade Hi-Toe wedges, Ping ChipR, Sik Putter.
