Skip to content
    • Tour Homepage
    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
    • Equipment Homepage
    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
    • Instruction Homepage
    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Magazine
    • Why walking is how golf is meant to be played
    • Why walking is the only way to truly appreciate a golf course
    • Is walking in golf just as important as the swing?
    • NCG recommends: Nine US public golf courses you should walk when you are in the country
National Club GolferNational Club Golfer Logo
  • TourHas submenu items

    Tour Homepage

    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
  • EquipmentHas submenu items

    Equipment Homepage

    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
  • ClubHas submenu items
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
  • InstructionHas submenu items

    Instruction Homepage

    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
  • CoursesHas submenu items
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
  • PodcastsHas submenu items
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Magazine
  • The Joy of WalkingHas submenu items
    • Why walking is how golf is meant to be played
    • Why walking is the only way to truly appreciate a golf course
    • Is walking in golf just as important as the swing?
    • NCG recommends: Nine US public golf courses you should walk when you are in the country

Sign up here for our newsletter and you'll never slice a drive again. Promise.

Newsletter sign up

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
National Club Golfer Logo

© 2026 National Club Golfer | 2 Arena Park, Tam Lane, LS17 9BF

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Policy
  • Meet the NCG Team
  • Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions
Country: gb Page generated at: Tuesday, 14 July 2026 at 1:25:51 British Summer Time
club
Weeding out the cheats: Taking on the role of a rules secretary

published: Jan 17, 2019

|

updated: Apr 5, 2024

Weeding out the cheats: Taking on the role of a rules secretary

Steve CarrollLink

FacebookXInstagramYouTubePodcast0 comments

Getting to grips with the 2019 rules has had unfortunate consequences for Steve Carroll. Our club golf editor reveals he has been saddled with an unenviable job

Weeding out the cheats: Taking on the role of a rules secretary

Table of Contents

Jump to:

  • will you be putting with the flagstick in?
  • why i’m struggling to come to terms with the new rules of golf
  • a dummy’s guide to the 2019 rules of golf

I’m stuck in a four-way discussion that is getting more daggers drawn with every second.

Veins aren’t quite popping yet, and no one has reached for their 7-iron, but there is definitely a deepening shade of crimson appearing on a couple of the foreheads.

I want to be involved in this as much as I’d like a particularly bad case of winter flu, but my presence is mandatory.

The trio momentarily cease bickering, turn to me in unison and ask those four words I dread: “What do you think?”

The worst of it is I knew this was coming. Delivering NCG’s content on the 2019 Rules of Golf changes had an unfortunate side effect: I’m now everyone’s go-to for an expert opinion.

But all I’ve done is one thing more than most club golfers – which is to actually read the rule book – and that has made me ‘qualified’ to take on the role of Sandburn Hall’s new rules and competition secretary.

Now before you play the world’s smallest violin for me, I did not accept the role oblivious to the trauma I was likely to face.

For it has struck me in my two decades as a club member that when it comes to talking to people about the decrees that bind us, you are sure to encounter three types of player – thorns, if you will, amid the otherwise lovely roses.

So far I have not been disappointed…

1. The ignorant

This crowd are your meat and drink as a rules official in competitions. You see, there is this thing called ‘club rules’.

It’s how that fourball who have been going out every Saturday morning since Britain invaded Suez play the game.

How many of the rules they stick to – or just know – depends on some of the personalities in the group, but, largely, they are playing a bastardised version of the game that only exists in their heads.

Advertisement

It’s the one that allows them to mow a lawn behind their ball in the rough, or take creative drops from unplayable positions in a treacherous gorse bush.

A long time ago, I had a ‘discussion’ with a player who grounded his club while trying to use a chipper out of a bunker.

Now we can debate the folly of that shot another time but what caused the brouhaha was my insistence that you couldn’t touch the sand during the backswing.

Our idiot firstly insisted he could and, when this was falling on deaf ears, then opted for a new strategy of complete denial.

Not even the trail left by the arc of his club scraping through the wet sand could elicit a mea culpa.

2. The know-it-all

I recently asked a very senior championship referee how he managed to learn every law, subsection and interpretation included in the massive 520-page guide book.

His answer surprised me. He didn’t know them all, or at least not to the detail you might expect.

What he did know, though, was where to find the answers in that book. If he had a tricky decision to make, and he wasn’t quite sure what to do, he could locate the page he needed within seconds.

It struck me that he wasn’t so much a deliverer of the rules as a librarian.

Anyhow, what this leads to is this: if a person whose role it is to know the rules inside and out can admit that certain nuances escape him, what makes some members think they could put John Humphrys in his place on Mastermind?

If you’re going to ask me a question about the rules, I’m going to try and find the answer. What I’m not going to do, as we discuss the scenarios, is humour the know-it-all’s lexicon, which usually includes the following phrases…

Well, I think you’ll find…

You are completely wrong and you can ask [insert governing body here].

And my personal favourite:

You need to learn the rules of golf.

I know perfectly reasonable people whose tone of voice changes completely when there is the mere scent of a discussion about immovable obstructions.

3. The Cheat

rules of golf

At best a rogue or a bandit. At worst a full-blown cheat.

They prey on the weakness of most of us – a craven desire to avoid any kind of conflict.

After all, this is our leisure time. The last thing we want on an enjoyable four-hour jaunt with our mates is to get into a ruck.

But all of us know these people.

They’re the ones who miraculously find their ball 50 yards from where everyone else in the group watched it enter the cabbage, the ones who hardly ever turn out in a medal but swoop in and clean up a team comp and the ones who can never remember whether they’ve had a four or a five.

So how did it end up as a three on the scorecard?

The rules secretary would like nothing better than to march in like a sheriff in a western and clean up this goddamn town.

But, and it’s perfectly understandable, no one wants to stick their head above the parapet and scream “J’accuse!”

Without evidence you can only narrow your eyes and pretend you’re about to have CCTV installed on every tee and green.

Fortunately, like natural selection, the inherent laws of the club often deliver their own swift justice.

These cads won’t be expelled as members but neither will they find it easy to get a game as names disappear from the tee sheet whenever theirs appears.

Advertisement

Usually, browbeaten and haggard, they simply disappear around renewal time. Never to be heard of again, until the familiar cries of anguish are detected from a nearby club.

putting with flag in

Will you be putting with the flagstick in?

Read full article - Will you be putting with the flagstick in?
Tending the flag

Why I’m struggling to come to terms with the new Rules of Golf

Read full article - Why I’m struggling to come to terms with the new Rules of Golf
2019 rules of golf

A dummy’s guide to the 2019 Rules of Golf

Read full article - A dummy’s guide to the 2019 Rules of Golf

Advertisement

About the author

Steve Carroll
Steve Carroll

A journalist for more than 25 years, Steve has been immersed in club golf for almost as long.

A former club captain, he has passed the Level 3 Rules of Golf exam with distinction having attended the R&A’s prestigious Tournament Administrators and Referees Seminar.

Steve has officiated at a host of high-profile tournaments, including Open Regional Qualifying, PGA Fourball Championship, English Men’s Senior Amateur, and the North of England Amateur Championship. In 2023, he made his international debut as part of the team that refereed England vs Switzerland U16 girls.

A part of NCG’s Top 100s panel, Steve has a particular love of links golf and is frantically trying to restore his single-figure handicap. He’d like to tell you he floats around 10. The reality is more like 13.

Steve plays at Sandburn Hall, in York, and is a country member at Close House in Newcastle. He has served on various club committees during his time in the game, and is the current Rules Secretary at Sandburn.

Having studied history at Newcastle University, he became a journalist having passed his NCTJ exams at Darlington College of Technology. He began his career working on weekly papers in Newcastle, before joining the York Press in 2001. After five years as a news reporter, he joined the sports desk – specialising in horse racing and snooker – and was Digital Sports Editor when he joined National Club Golfer in 2016.

What’s in Steve’s bag: TaylorMade Stealth 2 driver, 3-wood, and hybrids; Caley 01T irons 4-PW; TaylorMade Hi-Toe wedges, Odyssey 2Ball Microhinge putter.

Twitter

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

What's Popular

lost golf ball rule

You find your ball in the rough – then it disappears. What do the Rules say?

By Steve Carroll | Jun 30, 2026

Read full article You find your ball in the rough – then it disappears. What do the Rules say?
Golfer on their mobile phone | Source: Adobe Stock

I’ve changed my mind on mobile phones – they shouldn’t be anywhere near the golf course

By Steve Carroll | Jul 8, 2026

Read full article I’ve changed my mind on mobile phones – they shouldn’t be anywhere near the golf course
SOUTHAMPTON, NY - JUNE 17: Brooks Koepka of the United States celebrates with the U.S. Open Championship trophy after winning the 2018 U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills Golf Club on June 17, 2018 in Southampton, New York. (Photo by Andrew Redington/Getty Images)

What are the US Open cut rules?

By Matt Coles | May 9, 2025

Read full article What are the US Open cut rules?
Bryson DeChambeau at LIV Golf Korea | Source: LIV Golf

Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?

By Matt Chivers | Jun 10, 2026

Read full article Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?

Best Golf Balls for Seniors 2026: Distance and feel for those with slower swing speeds

By Max Mcvittie | Jul 10, 2026

Read full article Best Golf Balls for Seniors 2026: Distance and feel for those with slower swing speeds
A giant pitch mark on a golf green | Source: NCG

‘We don’t teach people how to play golf anymore’: Do we need to start handing out etiquette lessons at clubs?

By Steve Carroll | Jun 26, 2026

Read full article ‘We don’t teach people how to play golf anymore’: Do we need to start handing out etiquette lessons at clubs?
Martin Kaymer of the LIV Golf Cleeks team | Source: Getty Images

Big DP World Tour events still allow LIV Golfers to compete, but how?

By Matt Chivers | Jun 29, 2026

Read full article Big DP World Tour events still allow LIV Golfers to compete, but how?

Best Budget Irons 2026

By | Jun 18, 2026

Read full article Best Budget Irons 2026
SOUTHAMPTON, NEW YORK - JUNE 15: Jon Rahm of Spain looks on prior to the 126th 2026 U.S. OPEN at Shinnecock Hills Golf Club on June 15, 2026 in Southampton, New York. (Photo by Andrew Redington/Getty Images)

Stroke penalties are the perfect antidote to the most entitled and poorly behaved brats in professional golf

By Matt Chivers | Jun 25, 2026

Read full article Stroke penalties are the perfect antidote to the most entitled and poorly behaved brats in professional golf
richest golfers of all time

Who are the richest golfers of all time?

By Matt Chivers | Oct 1, 2025

Read full article Who are the richest golfers of all time?
Best Golf Balls 2026 | Source: NCG

Best Golf Balls 2026: The Ultimate Guide for Every Swing Speed and Handicap!

By Max Mcvittie | Jun 23, 2026

Read full article Best Golf Balls 2026: The Ultimate Guide for Every Swing Speed and Handicap!
The 18th Hole and 9th Hole of Shinnecock Hills Golf Club in the Southampton, N.Y. on Monday, Sept. 15, 2025. (Copyright USGA/John Mummert)

How much does it cost to play at Shinnecock Hills?

By Matt Chivers | Jun 14, 2026

Read full article How much does it cost to play at Shinnecock Hills?