Skip to content
    • Tour Homepage
    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
    • Equipment Homepage
    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
    • Instruction Homepage
    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Magazine
    • Why walking is how golf is meant to be played
National Club GolferNational Club Golfer Logo
  • TourHas submenu items

    Tour Homepage

    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
  • EquipmentHas submenu items

    Equipment Homepage

    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
  • ClubHas submenu items
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
  • InstructionHas submenu items

    Instruction Homepage

    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
  • CoursesHas submenu items
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
  • PodcastsHas submenu items
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Magazine
  • The Joy of WalkingHas submenu items
    • Why walking is how golf is meant to be played

Sign up here for our newsletter and you'll never slice a drive again. Promise.

Newsletter sign up

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
National Club Golfer Logo

© 2026 National Club Golfer | 2 Arena Park, Tam Lane, LS17 9BF

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Policy
  • Meet the NCG Team
  • Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions
Country: gb Page generated at: Friday, 22 May 2026 at 17:36:35 British Summer Time
tour
Tour
My week in golf: ‘Putt’ off by the 3 club rule?

published: Dec 6, 2016

|

updated: Oct 3, 2023

My week in golf: ‘Putt’ off by the 3 club rule?

Steve CarrollLink

FacebookXInstagramYouTubePodcast0 comments

It’s an acquired taste for some, but our club golfer can’t get enough of the ‘2 club and putter’…

putter

The EU referendum hardly got a squeak. The only thing most of us know about Trump was he did up Turnberry.

Seismic events that turned the world upside down in 2016 barely moved the needle in our clubhouse.

A mention of the 2 club and putter competition, though, is enough to send some of our members marching off down the 1st waving placards.

Nothing divides opinion more at Sandburn Hall – the club near York where I tee it up every week – than this novelty competition.

It’s a bit of fun as the year ends, some light relief following a campaign of tough competition and a succession of .1s.

The premise is very simple. Take one putter, add two other clubs, and compete in an 18-hole Stableford off full handicap.

Cards on the table, I’m a big fan of the format and probably take it a bit more seriously than I should.

Two days before the event, I was out at Moor Allerton trying out different club combinations in a bid to find the optimal bag configuration.

I never put this sort of practice in for a medal.

But while I’m a glass half full kind of guy when it comes to the three club rule, there are others who are throwing their container off a very large cliff and watching it smash into a thousand pieces below.

‘It isn’t proper golf’, they complain, arguing the short days and even shorter temperatures are enough of a restriction on their weekend golf fix without forcing them to leave 11 of their bats at home.

I play in a Saturday group that can number more than two dozen during the weekly roll-up. For the two club and putter, only three of us turned up.

After extensive testing, I had opted for a driver and a 7-iron to accompany my flat stick on the journey.

Advertisement

I tried very hard to fit a hybrid in there, on the grounds I could hit it on some of the longer par 3s.

Now everyone has seemingly decided the TaylorMade M2 is the best driver in the world, however, it felt like folly to leave my magic wand sitting on the sidelines.

If it’s good enough for Tiger and Rory…

Having opted for the big dog, I was then forced into a mid-iron compromise. I couldn’t well put a wedge in there after that, could I?

So I knew I was going to be struggling on a couple of par 3s.

And God help me if I landed in a bunker.

I mused the extra length I’d get off the tee, and the versatility of the 7, might make up for having to bunt one in from anywhere under 150 yards.

This strategy looked like sheer folly when I double bogeyed the opening hole – a par 5.

This was surely where my carefully constructed plan would be at its best. Driver, 7-iron, 7-iron, two putts.

But if you fat your first iron, you’re in a bit of trouble. The whole thing was in danger of becoming a house of cards.

When I got a drive out of the middle, though, good things were happening.

I birdied the 2nd – stiffing the 7 from 145 yards to 3 feet – and was still thereabouts standing on the tee of the 7th.

A mid-iron, unfortunately, has less versatility when you’re trying to strike it out of cabbage.

After being slapped in the face by a branch negotiating a tricky lie (my drive had not been accurate), I succumbed to the inevitable blob.

Then I tried to hit a cut fade with a gripped down driver on our 180-yard par 3 8th only for the ball, inevitably, to stay completely straight.

This is what I like about this competition, though. It forces you to think about the game in different ways.

You have to be inventive. You have to plot your way round.

There’s something very satisfying about hitting the perfect shot with a club that’s completely unsuited to the situation.

When I rolled through our front 9 the next day in a mere 38 strokes, I was convinced I’d also been helped by having much improved tempo.

It’s amazing how well you can hit a club when you know you can’t reach the green and aren’t trying to hit the cover off the ball.

These were fringe benefits. There were no prizes to pick up, unfortunately. 31 points doesn’t cut the mustard.

But that won’t stop me signing up again next year. I’ll never be put off from the two club and putter.

 

Advertisement

About the author

Steve Carroll
Steve Carroll

A journalist for more than 25 years, Steve has been immersed in club golf for almost as long.

A former club captain, he has passed the Level 3 Rules of Golf exam with distinction having attended the R&A’s prestigious Tournament Administrators and Referees Seminar.

Steve has officiated at a host of high-profile tournaments, including Open Regional Qualifying, PGA Fourball Championship, English Men’s Senior Amateur, and the North of England Amateur Championship. In 2023, he made his international debut as part of the team that refereed England vs Switzerland U16 girls.

A part of NCG’s Top 100s panel, Steve has a particular love of links golf and is frantically trying to restore his single-figure handicap. He’d like to tell you he floats around 10. The reality is more like 13.

Steve plays at Sandburn Hall, in York, and is a country member at Close House in Newcastle. He has served on various club committees during his time in the game, and is the current Rules Secretary at Sandburn.

Having studied history at Newcastle University, he became a journalist having passed his NCTJ exams at Darlington College of Technology. He began his career working on weekly papers in Newcastle, before joining the York Press in 2001. After five years as a news reporter, he joined the sports desk – specialising in horse racing and snooker – and was Digital Sports Editor when he joined National Club Golfer in 2016.

What’s in Steve’s bag: TaylorMade Stealth 2 driver, 3-wood, and hybrids; Caley 01T irons 4-PW; TaylorMade Hi-Toe wedges, Odyssey 2Ball Microhinge putter.

Twitter

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

What's Popular

David Feherty of the LIV Golf League | Source: Getty Images

LIV Golf’s David Feherty: I am in the dark like everyone else

By Matt Chivers | Apr 30, 2026

Read full article LIV Golf’s David Feherty: I am in the dark like everyone else
richest golfers of all time

Who are the richest golfers of all time?

By Matt Chivers | Oct 1, 2025

Read full article Who are the richest golfers of all time?
Is Tiger Woods playing in The Open

Where will The Open Championship be held in 2027, 2028 and 2029?

By Matt Chivers | Apr 27, 2026

Read full article Where will The Open Championship be held in 2027, 2028 and 2029?
MALELANE, SOUTH AFRICA - DECEMBER 05: Golf balls are seen on the practice facilitates prior to the Alfred Dunhill Championship at Leopard Creek Country Club on December 05, 2023 in Malelane, South Africa. (Photo by Luke Walker/Getty Images)

Can I get away with playing a ball that was out of bounds?

By Steve Carroll | Apr 27, 2026

Read full article Can I get away with playing a ball that was out of bounds?
First place individual champion, Captain Jon Rahm of Legion XIII celebrates on the 18th green after the final round of LIV Golf Mexico City at Club de Golf Chapultepec on Sunday, April 19, 2026 in Naucalpan, Mexico. (Photo by Jon Ferrey/LIV Golf)

Jon Rahm has finally made the right call on the DP World Tour – but is his biggest decision yet to come?

By Matt Chivers | May 5, 2026

Read full article Jon Rahm has finally made the right call on the DP World Tour – but is his biggest decision yet to come?
David Puig of LIV Golf | Source: Getty Images

Big DP World Tour events still allow LIV Golfers to compete, but how?

By Matt Chivers | Apr 27, 2026

Read full article Big DP World Tour events still allow LIV Golfers to compete, but how?
Masters champion Rory McIlroy of Northern Ireland waits to putt during the final round of the Masters at Augusta National Golf Club, Sunday, April 12, 2026 | Source: Logan Whitton

The Putter behind Rory’s Masters wins: Review and where to get it!

By Jack Backhouse | Apr 13, 2026

Read full article The Putter behind Rory’s Masters wins: Review and where to get it!
golfers private jets

Which golfers own private jets and how much do they cost?

By Matt Coles | Oct 16, 2025

Read full article Which golfers own private jets and how much do they cost?
Bryson DeChambeau at LIV Golf Korea | Source: LIV Golf

Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?

By Matt Chivers | May 20, 2026

Read full article Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?
Group of elderly men , businesspeople and senior enjoy outdoor sport golfing together at country club . Healthy men golfer holding golf stick on fairway with talking together at summer sunset. High quality photo | Source: Adobe Stock World Handicap System

Does the World Handicap System need to be the same across Great Britain & Ireland?

By Steve Carroll | May 3, 2026

Read full article Does the World Handicap System need to be the same across Great Britain & Ireland?
Fans display Justin Rose of Team Europe, Jon Rahm of Team Europe, Tommy Fleetwood of Team Europe and Rory McIlroy of Team Europe cut outs during the Sunday singles matches of the 2025 Ryder Cup at Black Course at Bethpage State Park Golf Course on September 28, 2025 in Farmingdale, New York. (Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images)

Ticket prices are just one feature of the ugly mess that the Ryder Cup has become

By Matt Chivers | Apr 23, 2026

Read full article Ticket prices are just one feature of the ugly mess that the Ryder Cup has become

Best Budget Irons 2026

By | Mar 5, 2026

Read full article Best Budget Irons 2026