fbpx
The Niggle: How long should we honour our champions

The Niggle: How long should we honour our champions

Should past major champions automatically receive lifetime exemptions, or should the current rules apply?
 

DM: This is going to come up in July, which will almost certainly be Tom Watson’s last Open – unless he does something ridiculous like nearly wins it some 30 years after his heyday, but that’s a ludicrous suggestion…

As it stands in the Open, you can play until you are 60, and past champions earn a four-year exemption by finishing inside the top 10, which is what Watson is currently using.

As a spectator and fan, I would contend that seeing past champions at the Open does nothing but enhance the experience, and I would rather encounter Mark Calcavecchia, for example, than Masanori Kobayashi (Japan Open champion) or Rhein Gibson (Australian IFQ graduate) at Hoylake.

Harrington’s situation is a little different – he’s missed out on the Masters and US Open but will of course be at the final two Majors of the season as a past champion. That feels about right to me and serves as a sobering reminder how quickly a professional golfer can fall from superstar to rank and file.

The reality is that if Harrington was good enough to play in this year’s US Open then he would have qualified outright MT: Previous winners of the US Open are eligible for 10 years – I’d quite like it if, like the other Majors, they received an invite up until they reach a certain age, say, 55. While you want the strongest field etc the week is added to nicely with the stories of what has gone before in the championship.

 

JT: I think ten years is about right for the US Open. You always want the best players of the day playing in Majors and if you had too many past champions in the tournament it could start devaluing the field. I don’t want to see other Majors go the way of the Masters and allow all past champions to play because I think it makes for a better tournament without some of them. The reality is that if Harrington was good enough to play in this year’s US Open then he would have qualified outright. There are 15 exemption categories along with international qualifying after all! The only point I would add is that it might be nice to allow players who win a Major three times a lifetime exemption. That would mean some truly great stars of the past would always get to play in an event that they helped shape the history of.

JM: Former major winners, along with the Amateur champion and US Amateur winner should be allowed to play for as long as their name is on the trophy!


Our team have had their say on the issue, but what do you think? Let us know by commenting below

Tom Irwin

Tom Irwin

Tom is a lifetime golfer, now over 30 years playing the game. 2023 marks 10 years in golf publishing and he is still holding down a + handicap at Alwoodley in Leeds. He has played over 600 golf courses, and has been a member of at least four including his first love Louth, in Lincolnshire. Tom likes unbranded clothing, natural fibres, and pencil bags. Seacroft in Lincolnshire is where it starts and ends.

Latest Posts

golf club membership fees

Features

Paul Lawrie: Golf club memberships aren’t expensive – but you need to play

By

Read full article about Paul Lawrie: Golf club memberships aren’t expensive – but you need to play
golf dress code

Is a relaxed dress code the key to youngsters playing golf?

By

Read full article about Is a relaxed dress code the key to youngsters playing golf?
min woo lee

Open de France betting – who tames Le Golf National?

By

Read full article about Open de France betting – who tames Le Golf National?
Solheim Cup betting

Solheim Cup betting: What are the best markets this week?

By

Read full article about Solheim Cup betting: What are the best markets this week?
shane lowry golf betting tips

BMW PGA Championship betting tips: Who wins at Wentworth?

By

Read full article about BMW PGA Championship betting tips: Who wins at Wentworth?
Tyrrell Hatton witb 2024

Horizon Irish Open betting tips – who wins at the K Club?

By

Read full article about Horizon Irish Open betting tips – who wins at the K Club?
Omega European Masters betting

Omega European Masters betting tips – Who wins in Crans-sur-Sierre?

By

Read full article about Omega European Masters betting tips – Who wins in Crans-sur-Sierre?
Britain's best nine-hole courses

Courses and Travel

Britain’s top 100 nine-hole courses: The NCG guide

By

Read full article about Britain’s top 100 nine-hole courses: The NCG guide
eddie pepperell

ISPS Handa World Invitational betting tips

By

Read full article about ISPS Handa World Invitational betting tips