Skip to content
    • Tour Homepage
    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
    • Equipment Homepage
    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
    • Instruction Homepage
    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Digital Magazine
National Club GolferNational Club Golfer Logo
  • TourHas submenu items

    Tour Homepage

    • PGA Tour
    • LIV Golf
    • DP World Tour
    • LPGA
    • LET
    • The Masters
    • The Open
    • The Players
    • US Open
    • PGA Championship
    • Ryder Cup
    • Solheim Cup
    • WITB
    • Betting
    • News
    • Features
  • EquipmentHas submenu items

    Equipment Homepage

    • Reviews
    • Drivers
    • Fairway Woods
    • Hybrids
    • Irons
    • Wedges
    • Putters
    • Golf Balls
    • DMDs
    • Apparel
    • Shoes
    • Trolleys
    • Features
    • News
  • Buying Advice
  • ClubHas submenu items
    • Rules
    • WHS
    • Features
    • News
  • InstructionHas submenu items

    Instruction Homepage

    • Driving Tips
    • Long Game
    • Iron Play
    • Short Game
    • Putting
    • Learn from the pros
    • Course Management
    • Fitness
    • Mental Game
    • Nutrition
  • Giveaways
  • CoursesHas submenu items
    • Top 100 Rankings
    • Travel
    • Top 100s Tour
    • Society Guide
  • PodcastsHas submenu items
    • NCG Golf Podcast
    • NCG Top 100s Podcast
    • Your Golf Podcast by NCG
  • Digital Magazine

Sign up here for our newsletter and you'll never slice a drive again. Promise.

Newsletter sign up

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
National Club Golfer Logo

© 2026 National Club Golfer | 2 Arena Park, Tam Lane, LS17 9BF

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Editorial Policy
  • Meet the NCG Team
  • Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions
Country: gb Page generated at: Friday, 3 April 2026 at 13:30:45 British Summer Time
tour
PGA Tour
Another rules controversy blights golf as US cruise at Presidents Cup

published: Oct 1, 2017

|

updated: Sep 23, 2024

Another rules controversy blights golf as US cruise at Presidents Cup

Mark TownsendLink

FacebookXInstagramYouTubePodcast0 comments

The US made light work of the International team to retain the 2017 Presidents Cup – but not before another rules fiasco…

Presidents Cup

What happened at the Presidents Cup?

Anirban Lahiri had to birdie the 16th and 17th holes in the Saturday afternoon fourballs to prevent the US closing out the Internationals a day early, something which has never happened in either the Presidents or Ryder Cups. It was that one-sided.

On Sunday, needing just one of the 12 singles, it was all over by the time Daniel Berger had beaten Kim in the fourth match out. The final score was 19-11 but that didn’t even reflect what a drubbing this was given that Nick Price’s side picked up seven and a half points on Sunday.

For the record the Americans have now won 10, halved one and lost one of the 12 overall matches – the US have won the last seven.

Dustin Johnson could have finished the week with a perfect 5-0 but was held to a half on Sunday by Branden Grace. Jordan Spieth, Justin Thomas and Patrick Reed all came into the singles with three wins and a half from the first three days but then all lost their head to heads.

For Phil Mickelson, who was the only American not to be part of the Tour Championship and who needed a captain’s pick, it was an undefeated week and he was one of three home winners in the singles, along with Rickie Fowler (also unbeaten) and Berger.

Mickelson is 47 now and this might be his final team outing for the United States. He has never been part of a victorious away team in the Ryder Cup and making the team in Paris will be one of his big goals for 2018.

Talking point – A Presidents Cup golf rules fiasco

So onto that rules fiasco.

The Jordan Spieth and Patrick Reed vs. Jason Day and Louis Oosthuizen showdown was all square at the short par-4 12th.

Day pitched his second shot to tap-in range and the Americans conceded the birdie.

Advertisement

Oosthuizen, whose drive had just fallen off the back of the green, attempted his eagle putt. But as it scuttled past the hole, Spieth, knowing his playing partner was already down for three, scooped up Oosthuizen’s still-moving ball and tossed it back to him.

But before Spieth and Reed could attempt their birdie putts, match referee Andy McFee stepped in and disqualified Spieth because stopping a ball still in motion is against the rules.

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

Day and Oosthuizen tried to argue on behalf of their opponents, but to no avail. Ridiculous? Of course, but the official was only doing his job. Hate the game, not the player.

For what it’s worth, the incident put the Internationals one up but the US recovered to take the match 2&1.

Shots of the week

Daniel Berger was left out of the Saturday morning foursomes. Here’s how he got into his fourball match alongside Justin Thomas in the afternoon.

With his feet in the hazard and almost in the water the American faced a pitch of 76 yards with the clever money on him toppling back into the drink.

And then this happened…

He and Thomas beat Hideki Matsuyama and Jhonattan Vegas 3&2.

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

The only way Justin Thomas can stop this thing is by hitting the..oh

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

Tweets of the week

When celebrations go wrong…

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

When celebrations are just really, really, really odd… Apparently it’s from the Three Amigos which might not be that apparent from these moves.

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

Jordan Spieth when asked about his favourite chant from the crowds…

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

And finally…

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

Quote of the week

“I thought we were going to have to get another captain out here to carry his stones”

Justin Thomas on his partner Berger after he knocked in five birdies in the Saturday fourballs.

“This is just between me and Spieth”

McFee doesn’t care if you’re Tiger Woods.

[object Object][object Object][object Object]

“They got a standing ovation when they walked in our team room tonight”

Internationals captain Nick Price on Lahiri and Kim’s Saturday afternoon victory which prevented it being all over in three days.

Best dressed

Here’s Mr FedEx rocking the stars and stripes bobble. Everything about this look is basically tremendous.

Worst dressed – Matt Kuchar

For this category the words ‘Matt Kuchar’ in Getty’s search bar generally gets the job done. But this could have been any of the Americans on Sunday and centres squarely around the colour of their trousers.

There is a darts player called Martin ‘Wolfie’ Adams who has relied on this colour of slack over the years and, every single time, they have looked abysmal. As was the case here in New Jersey.

I understand the red, white and blue thing but there are far better combinations to involve all three colours.

NOW READ: The worst Presidents Cup outfits

NOW READ: Donald Trump to Kim Jon-il – world leaders that loved to tee up

What did you make of the Presidents Cup rules fiasco? Tell us on X!

Advertisement

About the author

Mark Townsend

Been watching and playing golf since the early 80s and generally still stuck in this period. Huge fan of all things Robert Rock, less so white belts. Handicap of 8, fragile mind and short game

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

What's Popular

Jon Rahm playing for Legion XIII | Source: Getty Images

Why we could be watching the beginning of the end for LIV Golf

By Matt Chivers | Mar 23, 2026

Read full article Why we could be watching the beginning of the end for LIV Golf
Akshay Bhatia

Who is Akshay Bhatia?

By Matt Coles | Nov 8, 2024

Read full article Who is Akshay Bhatia?
Brian Gay retrieves his ball from a penalty area on the first hole during the third round of the Regions Tradition at Greystone Golf and Country Club on May 14, 2022 in Birmingham, Alabama. (Photo by Dylan Buell/Getty Images)

Why are penalty areas marked red or yellow?

By Steve Carroll | Mar 25, 2026

Read full article Why are penalty areas marked red or yellow?
highest paid caddies

Who are the highest-paid caddies in golf? The figures might shock you…

By Samuel Neale | Oct 21, 2025

Read full article Who are the highest-paid caddies in golf? The figures might shock you…
foursomes Golfers at a green | Source: Adobe Stock

Why do club golfers hate foursomes?

By Steve Carroll | Mar 16, 2026

Read full article Why do club golfers hate foursomes?
Bryson DeChambeau at LIV Golf Korea | Source: LIV Golf

Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?

By Matt Chivers | Mar 26, 2026

Read full article Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?
(Back L-R) Bernd Wiesberger of Austria and team Europe, Matthew Fitzpatrick of England and team Europe, Tommy Fleetwood of England and team Europe, Paul Casey of England and team Europe, Viktor Hovland of Norway and team Europe, Tyrrell Hatton of England and team Europe, Shane Lowry of Ireland and team Europe, Ian Poulter of England and team Europe, (Front L-R) Jon Rahm of Spain and team Europe, Lee Westwood of England and team Europe, captain Padraig Harrington of Ireland and team Europe, Sergio Garcia of Spain and team Europe, and Rory McIlroy of Northern Ireland and team Europe pose for a team photo prior to the 43rd Ryder Cup at Whistling Straits | Getty Images

Why should we care if Jon Rahm misses the Ryder Cup?

By Matt Chivers | Mar 26, 2026

Read full article Why should we care if Jon Rahm misses the Ryder Cup?
golfers private jets

Which golfers own private jets and how much do they cost?

By Matt Coles | Oct 16, 2025

Read full article Which golfers own private jets and how much do they cost?
Jordan Spieth walking on a golf course with a club, at the 2025 Hero World Challenge

Jordan Spieth could lose his PGA Tour card. Where on earth did it all go wrong?

By Matt Chivers | Feb 13, 2026

Read full article Jordan Spieth could lose his PGA Tour card. Where on earth did it all go wrong?

Golf Giveaways: Win a full TaylorMade custom fitting experience at The Kingdom at The Grove

By Paul Miller | Mar 20, 2026

Read full article Golf Giveaways: Win a full TaylorMade custom fitting experience at The Kingdom at The Grove
An image from LIV Golf Dallas | Source: LIV Golf

Big DP World Tour events still allow LIV Golfers to compete, but how?

By Matt Chivers | Mar 25, 2026

Read full article Big DP World Tour events still allow LIV Golfers to compete, but how?
Ganton Golf Club

The overlooked coastline offering some of the best-value golf in Britain and Ireland

By Max Mcvittie | Mar 11, 2026

Read full article The overlooked coastline offering some of the best-value golf in Britain and Ireland