If we had given panellists the chance to bump one course up the list, which would they have played their joker on?

Royal Liverpool

I’m biased as a long-time member but I was quite surprised it didn’t make the top 10. I think it’s because you look out from the clubhouse and see this flat expanse of land and already give it minus marks. Once you’ve played it a lot you realise what an incredible course it is.

Dave Cannon

• Meet the panel

• View the list

The Grove

It certainly merits a higher placement than 89th, which typifies not so much a bias against modern design as a lack of appreciation of the merits of modern design in the list overall. This also applies to post-boom courses such as Jonathan Gaunt’s Linden Hall and Ramside Hall which didn’t even make the long list.

George Oldham

Walton Heath (Old)

It has all the attributes of a really top-quality course and a wonderful balance to both nines. Many heathlands have allowed trees to invade but Walton Heath has stayed true and is the same course that hosted the 1981 Ryder Cup.

Jim Banting

 

Royal St George’s

For me it’s quite clearly the best golf course in England. I’ll mention another one, which is Hollinwell. It’s not the best inland course in the country, which is Sunningdale, but it’s certainly second.

Steve Watton

 

Alwoodley

I think I’d like to see my home course a little higher. It’s come in at 15th but I think it’s one of the best heathlands in England. I might be biased but the more I go to other places I go back to Alwoodley and think it’s proper.

Tom Irwin

 

Royal Worlington and Newmarket

I think it is an excellent design. They used the land expertly well. The greens are superb.

Sean Arble

 

Fulford

I thought it was fantastic, it should have been much higher in the rankings.

Craig Higgs

 

Wallasey

I have to admit I was very surprised to see Wallasey down at No 62 because I count it as one of the best and most enjoyable links in England. I know several people who prefer it to Hoylake. I wouldn’t go quite that far but it’s not far away. Prince’s is far too low as well.

Colin Callander

 

Royal North Devon

I went in May on a sunny evening. I thought it was magnificent. It’s gone out of fashion recently. We have it up in the 30s, which is great, but I think it could have been much higher.

Dan Murphy

 

Royal Liverpool

It was in my top four courses but came outside the top 10. That one jumped out at me. I believed it would have been a lot higher.

John McLoughlin

 

Silloth

Silloth has charm, character, intrigue and an identity all of its own but at the same time presents the truest, and quite often, stiffest of challenges. It’s an inspirational course with an endless collection of brilliant holes.

Ed Battye

 

Trevose

Especially with how high nearby St Enodoc comes in.  And I definitely rate it above Perranporth. Trevose had evolved into more of a holiday course – but now they are making a concerted effort to bring some teeth back.

Dove Jones

 

Silloth

I feel it is a unique golf course. It’s done well in the list but I thought that it should have done even better.

Peter Rudd

• Meet the panel

• View the list