fbpx
Players gallery

Would you prefer a hole-in-one or an albatross?

They are two of the finest achievements in golf – but which would you rather have on your golfing CV? The Niggle team discuss
 

Dan Murphy: Speaking as someone…

Alex Perry: Here we go…

Dan Murphy: Speaking as someone who has managed a hole-in-one, an albatross, and a hole-in-one and an albatross with the same shot, I can answer this conclusively.

It’s an albatross – much rarer and therefore more special. A hole-in-one is amazing but you think you might get another one. An albatross feels like a once-in-a lifetime thing.

 

24859|c:520x330.img

Alex Perry: Speaking as someone…

Dan Murphy: Here we go…

Alex Perry: Speaking as someone who has had two holes-in-one, I’ll go for an albatross, too. As you say, not only is it more rare, it’s better for your scorecard.

You could ask a hundred golfers how many of each they’ve had, and I reckon half would say they’ve had an ace and none would say they’ve had an albatross.

I wonder if I would feel differently if I hadn’t already had a hole-in-one…

Mark Townsend: Should anyone know Royal Wimbledon then, back in ’87, I hit two Ben Hogan Apex 5-woods to the short par-5 7th. Four inches short from an albatross. They should have erected a plaque where the approach was dispatched from. Every time I have a chance of reaching a par 5 I think of that shot and then invariably tug it a bit left.

Tom Lenton: A hole-in-one for me, because I’ve haven’t had a proper one yet. A lot of people could say albatross though because they can’t actually reach the green in two…

James Savage: You say proper one like you’ve been cheated out of it. You were three off the tee so it was a par.

Christian Maiden: Easy. Hole-in-one. I’ve never been asked if I’ve ever had an albatross? And albatrosses are all flukes – you’re not aiming for the hole but the green, whereas when you shoot an ace you were actually aiming for the hole.

Alex Perry: Were you?

James Savage: I’m with Christian. When do you get asked about getting an albatross? Every time I stand on the tee box on a par 3 it goes through my head that this could be the one.

It must be like willing your football team to score from a corner in the last minute. The keeper comes up and heads it into the top corner – I know that feeling and it’s brilliant.

I’d never normally expect to reach a par 5 in two so would never be thinking about trying to get an albatross.
There’s a chance – albeit very slim – of a hole-in-one on every par 3. I want to get one so I can stop trying, and thinking about it, and so I can tell you all about it.

Craig Middleton: I think I’d prefer and albatross. A hole-in-one is always possible given it’s just one shot. An albatross you need to hit a cracking drive, and an inch perfect second. I feel I’d have more chance of making a hole-in-one than an albatross. If that makes sense.

Dan Murphy: Although I’ve now had two of them. But let’s not get into that again…

James Broadhurst: Seeing as I’ve never had either I would go for a hole-in-one. Just to get off the mark and I could do the hole bragging thing about where I got it.

However, I think an albatross would be more satisfying personally. I’ll get back to you when I have marked them both off the to do list…

Your say: So, what would you prefer to get? Let us know in the comments below, or join the conversation on Twitter and Facebook

Click here for the full Niggle archive

 

Latest Posts

dp world tour 2024 schedule

DP World Tour

DP World Tour 2024 schedule and results

Read full article - DP World Tour 2024 schedule and results
liv golf schedule 2024

LIV Golf

LIV Golf schedule 2024: Every date, venue and result

Read full article - LIV Golf schedule 2024: Every date, venue and result
Lydia Ko WITB

News

What’s in Lydia Ko’s bag?

Read full article - What’s in Lydia Ko’s bag?
players championship field 2024

News

Players Championship field: Who is playing at TPC Sawgrass?

Read full article - Players Championship field: Who is playing at TPC Sawgrass?
LIV Golf

LIV Golf

How far have the LIV golfers fallen in the world rankings?

Read full article - How far have the LIV golfers fallen in the world rankings?
pga championship field

News

World Golf Rankings 2024: Who’s in the top 10?

Read full article - World Golf Rankings 2024: Who’s in the top 10?
LIV Golf

LIV Golf

Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?

Read full article - Show me the money! How much has each LIV player made since signing up?
rory mcilroy talor gooch

News

Rory McIlroy’s advice for Talor Gooch: Be more like Joaquin Niemann!

Read full article - Rory McIlroy’s advice for Talor Gooch: Be more like Joaquin Niemann!
viktor hovland prize money

News

Soulless, comical and sad: Viktor Hovland has a bleak outlook on golf

Read full article - Soulless, comical and sad: Viktor Hovland has a bleak outlook on golf