fbpx

We sometimes use affiliate links to products and services on retailer sites for which we can receive compensation if you click on those links or make purchases through them.

 

NCG's 2015 Irons test - The results

NCG’s 2015 Irons test – The results

In the market for some new irons? Find out which one's faired best in our 2015 test
 

“The most thorough comparison you’ll read this year including all the brands you care about” 

The Testers


Dan Murphy
Handicap: 3
Current irons: Ping i25


“I’m looking for a conventional view at address, even gapping throughout the set and long irons I can have confidence in.”



20827|c:520x330.img



James Savage
Handicap: 17
Current irons: Titleist 714 AP1

“I’m quite greedy as I want something that looks stunning but also offers playability and forgiveness. As an improving golfer, I want something that will still suit as I (hopefully) get better.”

Dan’s awards (Click on the product for a detailed review)

Gold

Mizuno MP-15
Nike Vapor Pro Combo 

Silver
Ping i25

Bronze

Callaway XR Pro
Titleist 714 AP2 

20828|c:520x330.img

James’ awards

Gold
Mizuno JPX850 Forged

Silver
TaylorMade RSi1
Titleist 714 AP1
Ping G30

Bronze
Callaway XR
Nike Vapor Speed

20829|c:520x330.img

Best of the rest


Benross Hot Speed 10
Yonex Ezone XP
Benross Rip Speed 10
Adams XTD Forged
TaylorMade RSi 2
Cobra Fly-Z
Lynx Boom Boom
Yonex N1-CB forged
Cobra Fly-Z+


Dan’s verdict

In the end I had to make a choice did I go for reassuring forgiveness or out-and-out class. I was broadly fitted into these two types of irons and you can’t quite have it both ways. 


When hitting 4 irons, being honest, I’d rather be looking down at an i25 or an XR Pro. 


Standing over a wedge, there was no contest the likes of MP-15s, Vapor Pro Combos and AP2s with their thinner top lines are what I wanted to have in my hands. 


I have marginally leaned towards the latter on the basis that you spend more time hitting short irons than 4 and 5 irons.


The MP-15s stood out by oozing style and for the remarakable consistency of their performance. It’s a tribute to the outstanding Vapor Pro Combos that they were neck and neck. Just behind were the all-weather i25s. 



James’ verdict

There was balance to be struck when selecting a favourite iron from a collection this good. I want something that looks great but can also offer forgiveness and playability. 

With Mizuno’s JPX850 Forged I really felt like I was getting the complete package. It’s
not easy for mid-high handicappers to find an iron that looks like a player’s club but also suits their ability level.

The AP1s ran them very close on all fronts. The G30s didn’t quite deliver in the looks department but did exactly what I wanted to in performance. 

The RSi 1s had unrivalled forgiveness on mis-hits but just lacked a wow factor. The Vapor Speeds were only marked down on the grips, while the XRs were the kings of distance.
I’d happily put any in my bag.



How we conducted the test



The test took place at Moor Allerton GC, near Leeds. We started off inside using a Trackman launch monitor to

hit long and mid-iron shots and collect data on the performance. 


We then headed outside to hit from grass, paying particular attention to the short irons and hitting at targets. We used high- quality range balls. 


For more golf equipment news and reviews CLICK HERE

Latest Posts

Ping G Le3 review

Drivers

The Most Forgiving Clubs For Women? Ping G Le3 Golf Club Review

Read full article - The Most Forgiving Clubs For Women? Ping G Le3 Golf Club Review

Irons

Mizuno Pro 245 Irons Review

Read full article - Mizuno Pro 245 Irons Review
Wilson DynaPower Forged irons review

Irons

Wilson Dynapower Forged Irons Review

Read full article - Wilson Dynapower Forged Irons Review
Mizuno Pro 241 Irons Review

Irons

Mizuno Pro 241 Irons Review

Read full article - Mizuno Pro 241 Irons Review
TaylorMade Qi10: Everything you need to know!

Irons

TaylorMade Qi Iron Review

Read full article - TaylorMade Qi Iron Review
Cobra Darkspeed: Everything you need to know!

Cobra

Cobra Darkspeed: Everything you need to know!

Read full article - Cobra Darkspeed: Everything you need to know!
Wilson Staff Model Blades Irons Review

Irons

Wilson Staff Model Blades Irons Review

Read full article - Wilson Staff Model Blades Irons Review
Cobra DarkSpeed irons review

Irons

Cobra Darkspeed Irons Review

Read full article - Cobra Darkspeed Irons Review
Wilson Staff Model CB iron review

Irons

Wilson Staff Model CB Irons Review

Read full article - Wilson Staff Model CB Irons Review